Building New or Renovating: Which Is Right For Me?

Jul 13, 2022

It's an age-old question: If you are a homeowner and your existing living space just doesn't work anymore, should you do a gut renovation of your current home to suit your changing needs or start fresh and build new?


Of course, we here at Medallion Home believe that building new is almost always the right answer, but we know there are situations where a renovation is the best option. In this article, we'll weight the pros and cons of each. In the end, if you decide that building new in 2022 is for you, please connect with us! We'd be honored to be your home builder!


Building New

A new home looks great, works perfectly, and smells good, but that's not all.


Pros

  • You'll have more control over your project. From the design and layout to how it flows and functions.
  • All-new everything inside the house. And we do mean INSIDE - insulation, wiring, plumbing, and systems will all be brand new.
  • Everything in your home will meet or exceed existing building codes; no retrofitting involved!
  • Once your plans are set, you can sit back and let the process unfold before you.
  • New homes are built to appeal to a wide audience so it's easier to sell years from now if you want to; the value is already built in.
  • There is a popular misconception that new build homes take longer than renovations. Many times, a renovation takes longer than anticipated.


Cons

  • A new build can be more expensive than a renovation but it's worth it when every inch of your home is built to code, energy-efficient, and requires no up-front maintenance. Plus, you didn't have to live in a home that was being gutted and rebuilt!


Renovating

If you're in a neighborhood that you love or absolutely must stay in (for the school district or to be close to family, for example), doing a gut renovation of your existing home may be your only choice. Our best advice is to plan ahead, prepare for the unexpected, and have a flexible budget since renovation projects are notoriously unpredictable. However, there are a few pros to this option.


Pros

  • If done properly, a gut renovation can add to your existing home value.
  • If it's not an extensive project, the timeframe will seem shorter. That being said, a gut rebuild usually takes longer than estimated. Just ask anyone who's ever done it!
  • You get to stay in the home and neighborhood you love.


Cons

  • There are more design restrictions because you're bond by the size and structure of your existing house.
  • You can never be sure what you'll run into once you start tearing down walls and ripping up floors.
  • The older the building, the more costly it is to renovate. You'll need to bring everything up to code and there may even be mitigation work required if lead paint or asbestos are involved.
  • You may need to move out of the home or you could lose temporary access to important spaces like the kitchen or bathroom.
  • If you assume the role of Project Manager and are overseeing the process and the contractors, a renovation can get overwhelming very quickly.
  • The renovation may not translate to increased home value, especially if the design is too personalized.
  • According to the 2020 U.S. Houzz & Home Study: Renovation Trends, one-third of renovations go over budget.


At the end of the day, you'll make the decision that's best for you and your family. If that decision is to build a new home in one of the most desirable areas of Bradenton, Parrish, Mount Dora, or Sarasota, we're ready to get to work! Contact us for more information on building a new home that fits your needs.

Medallion Home reserves the right to change elevations, floor plans, specifications and prices without notice. All renderings, elevations, floor plans and maps are an artist’s conception, and are not intended to be an actual depiction of the buildings, fencing, walks, driveways or landscaping. All dimensions have been calculated from architectural drawings and may be subject to minor variations during construction. This web site is for informational purposes only, and should not be the sole basis of a decision to purchase any property. Please see our sales representatives with any questions. We do business in accordance with the Federal Fair Housing Law.

01 Apr, 2024
Though we don’t build homes for the awards, Medallion Home proudly showcases our homes at the Parade of Homes Manatee & Sarasota Counties each year. It’s a chance for us to show our quality craftsmanship and unique custom designs to prospective homebuyers and represent what they can expect from every home we build. This year was no different. We were honored to be among the top award-winning home builders and to be recognized for several of our homes throughout the area.
By Matthew F 16 Feb, 2024
Not far from the popular Florida cities of Sarasota, Bradenton, and Tampa lies a town that has been rapidly growing, but still manages to maintain its small-town charm. With the ideal blend of serene tropical living and an endless array of things to do, Parrish, Florida is a desirable haven on the Gulf Coast. And Medallion Home has a featured community to share with you: The Laurels Villas in Parrish.
By Matthew F 19 Dec, 2023
Moving to Florida soon? Here are some top home design trends in the state. Call us today for more information!
30 Nov, 2023
In Florida and throughout the country, PGT Impact Windows are the gold standard when it comes to storm protection. Here at Medallion Home, we initially offered these premium windows as an upgrade because of the investment but they provide so much benefit to the home and peace of mind to the homeowner that we've decided to make them our standard in every home we build. What Are Impact Windows? Impact windows combine heavy-duty aluminum frames with impact-resistant, laminated glass and a special silicone glazing process to keep the glass from breaking away from its frame. That means that during storms and hurricanes, if flying debris hits your windows, they will stay intact rather than shatter, protecting your home from the elements and people and pets from shards of glass. But these windows can do even more. Noise Reduction Your home should be your sanctuary, one where you leave the outside world at the door and that includes noise. Noise pollution is a very real thing and can disrupt your sleep at night, focus during work, or even a good movie night. PGT's impact windows reduce noise from outside by as much as 65%. UV Protection The sun's UV rays are good in small doses to help your body create essential Vitamin D, but there's really no good reason to have them flooding the interior of your home. These powerful rays can fade your furniture, flooring, and drapes, making these items look old and worn before their time. Impact windows can preserve the beauty of your home and help you save money by filtering out 99% of UV rays while still allowing in natural sunlight. Maximum Energy Savings Heating and cooling a home accounts for nearly half of the average American home's energy costs. Security About 23% of all home break-ins are accessed through a first-floor window. Impact windows are designed to withstand repeated impact from a 9-lb, 2x4 beam traveling at 34 miles per hour. It's very, very hard to break an Impact Window (if it can be done at all). It's not the kind of challenge most burglars want to face. Return on Investment For all the reasons above, particularly in Florida where tropical storms and hurricanes are a way of life, impact windows are appealing in any home. These specialty windows can yield as much as an 80% return on investment, ensuring that you'll get top dollar should you ever need to sell your home. Now Standard in All Medallion Homes High quality, impact-resistant windows shouldn't be luxuries - they should be standard features. That's why we now include them in every new home we build. Enjoy the benefits of increased storm protection, noise reduction, UV protection, savings, and security every day. Contact us to learn more.
By Alyson H 24 Aug, 2023
Welcome to the Watercolor Place Villas in Bradenton Florida. This community offers some of the best luxury homes in the state. Call today for more information!
By Alexis Udine 12 Jun, 2023
Are you looking to move to Florida? You've got to check out our most popular floor plan, St. Thomas!
By Alexis Udine 15 Apr, 2023
Once again it was fun and exciting to be part of the 2023 Parade of Homes Manatee & Sarasota Counties . It was also gratifying to have our unique homes recognized for so many awards! (Not that we’re counting… but that brings us up to 172 awards in 5 years!)
By Shanteller R 28 Feb, 2023
When searching for your next home, you’re undoubtedly looking for something that checks all the boxes. A beautifully designed home in a wonderful community, situated in a great location. At Medallion Home, we always want you to be able to check off every box on the list for your new home. That’s why we build homes with unsurpassed quality and uncompromising value in amazing communities in Southwest or Central Florida . Today we’d like to shine a spotlight on Watercolor Place in Bradenton, one of the most popular gated communities in Florida. A limited number of new lots have just been released, and are sure to sell quickly. Watercolor Place Is Our Charming & Contemporary Gated Community in Florida When searching for your next home, you’re undoubtedly looking for something that checks all the boxes. A beautifully designed home in a wonderful community, situated in a great location. At Medallion Home, we always want you to be able to check off every box on the list for your new home. That’s why we build homes with unsurpassed quality and uncompromising value in amazing communities in Southwest or Central Florida . Today we’d like to shine a spotlight on Watercolor Place in Bradenton, one of the most popular gated communities in Florida. A limited number of new lots have just been released, and are sure to sell quickly.
Is Parrish, Florida a Nice Place to Live?
21 Dec, 2022
Moving to Parrish, FL is a great decision if you’re looking for a wonderful place to call home. Take a look at our blog to learn more!
Best Time to Buy a New Home
31 Oct, 2022
Is now the right time to buy? The short answer — yes absolutely. Check out our blog to see a few reasons why.
More Posts
Share by: